Are we repeating their mistakes today?

by William V. McDonald

The Dead Sea Scrolls are perhaps the most important archaeological find in Israel to date.  Much has been written outlining the historical setting of the scrolls for the purpose of scholarly interpretation.  In this article I will discuss the people of Qumran--their identity and lifestyle in the isolated community of Qumran.

The Qumranites were members of a Jewish sect which moved to the Judean desert near the Dead Sea (and possibly also to Damascus).  They attempted to walk continually before the Lord in the ways of truth.  According to their Manual of Discipline, their major purpose was to study the Law.  Within the Qumran literature special importance was placed upon the Law.  The Qumranites believed that they alone had been given the purpose of walking by the Law and not deviating to the right or to the left.

Much emphasis was placed upon ethical, ritual, and ceremonial concepts such as truth, righteousness, kindness, covenant love, justice, chastity, and honesty.  These concepts are repeatedly mentioned in their literature. The Qumranites became a separated community apparently consisting of mostly men, having all things in common.  They also believed that they were the last generation, living at the end of the age.  According to the Qumran writings (1QM 1:5), this end time was for salvation and would be a time of peace and blessing to the people of God, whom they believed to be themselves.

The Qumran community believed the Bible was the word of God.  They had someone reading the Bible 24 hours a day, because of the verse, "My words shall not depart out of thy mouth day or night."  Their whole system of faith and life was built around such principles.

According to Dr. William S. LaSor, Professor Emeritus at Fuller Theological Seminary, history proved that these people were wrong in their beliefs.  LaSor points out five major factors which sealed the final history of the Qumran Community:

There is no doubt that one's personal beliefs can be strengthened by the study of such historical evidence.  One can clearly see the Qumranites' mistakes being repeated today.  As Dr. LaSor stated, history did in fact prove them wrong.  Will it prove us wrong if we don't learn from their mistakes?  They had but one interpretation.  They had no perspective.  Are not these same fallacies seen in the believing community today?  I believe that many things are being overemphasized by some believers; for example, the Second Coming, the Rapture of the Church, or centering the whole New Testament message upon evangelism.  These concepts are important and part of God's redemptive plan.  However, we must be cautious in our interpretation of Scripture--especially prophetic Scripture--keeping in mind the teaching of Paul, "Study to show yourself approved unto God, a workman who needs not be ashamed, rightly dividing the Word of Truth."  The Qumranites, by way of the Teacher of Righteousness, used proof texts, word plays, and allegoric teachings to make the text fit their interpretation.  Are we doing the same thing today?  Manipulation of the text got the Qumranites into trouble, and why should we assume that it will not get us into trouble as well?  If history is a judge, will the judge not hold us accountable for the same mistakes?

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

William McDonald, a senior at Oral Roberts University, is one of the students Yavo has been supporting for the last 3 years.  We're very proud of William.  Before returning to school, he had absolutely no background in college, and at the age of 36, he left his prospering tailor business in Peoria, Illinois, and undertook full-time study.  He graduated from junior college, moved to Tulsa and enrolled in O.R.U.  He is now in his senior year and plans to continue his graduate studies at O.R.U. and, hopefully, also in Israel.

William is supported in his studies by his lovely wife, Margaret, and his four children.

We are proud to be able to present this article to you from one of our students.  I believe you will agree that his paper indicates that he has much promise for the future in biblical studies.

Yavo Digest Vol. 1, No. 4, 1987

Bible Scholars: Question the Answers

BACK to Beit HaDerekh/Yavo

To Beit HaDerekh (House of the Way)

For comments, questions, or broken links, please e-mail me at johnt204(at)
Please copy and paste this   %%--%%--POQ--%%--%%   into the subject line of your email
so that I can notice it easier in case it goes to my spam folder. Thanks.

Last update 16 April 2020